According to the reviews online both NMIMS Mumbai and SIBM Pune have their fair share of pros and cons. THey each are better in their own way.
Here are some facts that will help you understand the similarities and differences of both the colleges:
Categories | NMIMS Mumbai | SIBM Pune |
Course Fee | INR 6.88 lakh | INR 19.4 lakh |
Placement Percentage | 80% | 70% |
Highest CTC | 16 LPA | 18 LPA |
Average CTC | 9 LPA | 6-7 LPA |
Recruiting Companies | TCS, Wipro, HP, Accenture, etc. | Tech Mahindra, Infosys, TCS, Accenture, etc. |
NMIMS also has a better, more experienced faculty than SIBM Pune. Being in the centre of the industrial hub, many companies participate in their placement program.
The Institute is located at the famous site of our National Capital. Listed below are various points that brief you about the marketing placements of the institute:
Categories |
Marketing at IMT Ghaziabad |
Course Fee |
19.53 lakh |
Placement Percentage |
95% |
Highest CTC |
30 LPA |
Average CTC |
15 LPA |
Recruiting Companies |
Godrej, Aditya Birla Fashion Retail, Deloitte, Cisco, ITC, cognizant and Accenture. |
So to say, being an aspirant, one should transparently perform a clear cost benefit analysis of going for an MBA depending on where the individual stands in their career. They also need to take into consideration whether they are a fresher or someone with a couple years of experience.
For marketing, NMIMS Mumbai is better. It has a great faculty pool for marketing. As Mumbai houses many MNCs, it's easy to get good exposure and placement opportunities. For placement, major sectors come for marketing, i.e. FMCG, FMCD, E-Commerce, Retail, etc. During NMIMS Mumbai placements 2021, FMCD/FMCG/Retail sector offered the highest CTC of INR 25 LPA.
IMT Ghaziabad is the best option for Marketing. It has an excellent student crowd. There are good opportunities for peer-to-peer learning. The competitive environment on campus motivates students to perform better. IMT has a brilliant Marketing faculty. The alumni of the institute are working in top positions in the marketing domain.
IMT Ghaziabad placements are good. Marketing students are recruited in core/sales/media/digital/advertisement roles. For Marketing, the salary packages offered are in the range of INR 8 LPA - 11.92 LPA.
XISS Ranchi has a NIRF Ranking of 76 and Bimtech has a NIRF Ranking of 47 for MBA. Bimtech and XISS Ranchi, both offer decent PGDM degree programs in Marketing specializations. Given below is a brief highlight of the MBA program offered by Bimtech and XISS Ranchi.
Parameters |
Bimtech |
XISS |
Grand total fees |
12 Lacs |
10 lacs |
Highest salary package |
18 LPA |
14 LPA |
Average salary package |
8 LPA |
6 LPA |
Admission:
Bimtech:
For PGDM, the applicants must have graduated with a minimum of 50% aggregate at Bimtech.
The candidate is required to have a valid score in CAT/XAT/CMAT/GMAT/MAT.
Applicants are then shortlisted for a personal interview and writing ability test.
The applicants need to fill the online application form from the website of the college and pay the application fee of INR 2000.
XISS Ranchi:
Admission for MBA at XISS through CAT/XAT/GMAT. The institute also conducts written tests and interviews for selection.
The applicants are required to fill the application form online from the official website of the institution. The application procedure at XISS includes registration from the official website of the institution, uploading of details and documents, payment of application form online of INR 2100.
Placements:
The top recruiters at Bimtech include Amazon, KPMG, Infosys, HDFC Bank.
96% of the total students from the Marketing stream got placed. The average placement in Marketing was 6 LPA. The top recruiters at XISS include JSLPS, ICICI, Mahindra Finance, HDFC Mutual fund, Allergen, etc.
In the stream of Marketing, the number of students placed is better in XISS however, the average placement stats are better in Bimtech. Both the colleges are good for Marketing.
If you're looking to specialize in marketing and work in fields such as strategic communication, advertising, and media management, then MICA would be the perfect fit for you. They offer a range of courses and programs that focus specifically on marketing, making it an ideal choice for those who want to go deep in this field.
However, if you're an engineer looking for a more general approach to sales and marketing, you may want to consider NMIMS Mumbai, SIBM Pune, or IMT Ghaziabad. All three institutes are similar in their approach to marketing, but each has its unique advantages and disadvantages.
NMIMS Mumbai, for example, has a higher cost and a smaller campus compared to SIBM and IMT. However, it also boasts a strong brand and alumni network, which can be very advantageous when it comes to finding jobs or internships. Additionally, the packages offered by NMIMS are generally higher than those at IMT and slightly better than SIBM.
On the other hand, SIBM Pune and IMT Ghaziabad offer a larger campus and a more affordable cost of attendance. However, they may not have the same level of brand recognition or alumni network as NMIMS Mumbai.
Ultimately, it comes down to what you value most in an institute. If you want a strong brand and alumni network and are willing to pay a higher cost for it, then NMIMS Mumbai might be the right choice for you. If you're looking for a more affordable option with a larger campus, then SIBM Pune or IMT Ghaziabad may be a better fit.
MICA university holds 12th rank issued by outlook in 2019. Admissions in this university are based on entrance tests followed by personal interview and counseling. Placements at this university are really good.
Symbiosis Center for Management & Human Resource Development (SCMHRD) holds 13th rank for MBA issued by times. Admissions for MBA are based on entrance tests followed by personal interview and group discussion.
Tabulated below gives a brief overview of both institutions:
Particulars |
SCMHRD |
MICA |
Application fee |
1000 INR |
1,965 INR |
Top recruiters |
Accenture, ACCENTURE, Avalon Consulting, Axis Bank, Bajaj Auto, Barclays Bank, Bridgei2 |
Raymond, Titan, Saavn, Walmart, Amazon, Google, Apollo, Linkedin, YesBank, Amazon, Puma, Usha and Topline |
Average salary |
15.6 lakhs |
12.8 lakhs |
Admission process
MICA
SCMHRD
Placements
SCMHRD
MICA
Infrastructure
SCMHRD
MICA
Overall both institutes are equally good for management. The admission process of both institutes is based on entrance tests conducted by institutes. Placements of both the institutes are equally good. Both institutes have an engaging and encouraging environment.
Indeed, IMI Delhi is one of the best colleges for Marketing in the country, consistently rated in the top 10 in the country. Their forte over the years has been the marketing depth their faculty brings to the table. If you don't have a choice to go for the top IIMs, I suggest you go for a marketing choice at IMI. Their placement record over the last decade has also been quite good.
The batch profile over there is pretty strong. You will find people from different cities, top colleges with core sales/advertising roles who add real value to the class. The mix of freshers and work-ex people is conducive to good placements. Also, the batch strength is not big, and hence the opportunities are immense.
IMI New Delhi has had an extremely diverse alumni base for the past 42 years with alumni like Akanksha Jain Bahl, who is working with Pepsico and handling their consumer insights. This rich alumni base gives you the required corporate exposure and industry insights.
So, in my opinion, if you are considering all these parameters while choosing a B-School, IMI New Delhi is a good option. The opportunities offered there are fair and immense.
XLRI offers a program in digital marketing through the Talentedge platform which is a 4 month online course. MICA on the other hand offers a certificate program in digital marketing which is for 5 months and offered online and through the upgrad platform.
Admissions:
Particulars |
MICA Digital Marketing |
XLRI Digital Marketing |
Eligibility criteria |
10+2+3 from a recognized University |
Minimum 3 years of work experience 10+2+3 from a recognized University |
NIRF Ranking |
Top 100 |
9th |
Total seats |
30 |
20 |
Fees |
INR 70,000 |
INR 70,000 |
MICA: Collaborations with Nanyang University, Queensland University and a few other top colleges from Europe help enhance knowledge and outlook. Internship opportunities are also provided with average stipend being 81,000 and highest stipend being over 1.5 lacs.
XLRI: Tie-ups with universities like Tulane, University of Virginia and many others help include top faculty members from across the globe who are also advisors at the World Bank, Ford Foundation, UN.
MICA: The course is spread across 7 modules with Business methods, Search Marketing, Social media marketing, Email marketing, Display marketing, Mobile marketing and Web analytics. They also conduct additional tutorial classes in between modules and learn inter-module dynamics of digital marketing channels.
XLRI: The course has a good mix of theory and practical subjects with a comprehensive capstone project at the end of the semester related to the different aspects of digital marketing. It has core subjects like strategic brand communication, digital media analytics, content marketing, marketing plan and more. The curriculum has been designed in a way to build and develop a better understanding towards digital marketing tools and manage digital campaigns.
Since these are certification courses, the institution does not offer direct placements but completing this course will surely allow professionals to further enhance their career and gain expertise in this field. This certificate course earned by professionals helps 70% of them to either find a higher paying job or start a new career.
You should choose IIM Calcutta. It is better in terms of peer group, faculty profiles, ranking across the country and abroad, location, alumni base, and placements. You will get better opportunities at IIM Calcutta.
As per the recent statistics, IIM Calcutta placements for the sales and marketing sector are pretty good. Almost 14% of students received placements in General Marketing and Marketing sector. The average CTC offered by the companies in this sector is INR 29 LPA.
IIM Calcutta also has a better brand value compared to IIM Lucknow. In the long run, you can benefit a lot from that.