The Article Shock Therapy for Mental Patients will be Reviewed Continues the Ignorant Tradition of Demonizing Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT)

Reading Passage Question:

The article Shock therapy for mental patients will be reviewed continues the ignorant tradition of demonizing electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) in the media (the very use of the anachronistic and misleading phrase shock therapy is unwarranted) without presenting the compelling reasons for its continued use. Most of the facts and quotations in the article, including the gratuitous final paragraph about pigs in an abattoir, are simply taken from an article by Davar in Issues in Medical Ethics, without questioning whether Davars presentation of the issue is an unbiased and scientifically accurate one. What Ms. Davar, and by extension Ms. Jain, has done is simply cite authorities who agree with her point of view, quote statistics without context, use an abundance of negative adjectives, and ignore outright the empirically proven benefits (often life-saving) of ECT in many categories of mentally-ill patients. This is shabby and irresponsible medical journalism. While this is not the place to dispute, point-by-point, Ms. Davars presentation of her position and Ms. Jains repetition of it, I would like to quote, to counter their negative emphasis, from Andrew Solomons widely read, intensively researched, highly respected book, The Noonday Demon: An Anatomy of Depression. Solomon writes: Antidepressants are effective [against major depression] about 50 percent of the time, perhaps a bit more; ECT seems to have some significant impact between 75 and 90 percent of the time.

Many patients feel substantially better within a few days of having an ECT treatment a boon particularly striking in contrast to the long, slow process of medication response. ECT is particularly appropriate for the severely suicidal for patients who repeatedly injure themselves and whose situation is therefore mortally urgent because of its rapid action and high response rate, and it is used in pregnant women, the sick, and the elderly, because it does not have the systemic side effects or drug-interaction problems of most medications.

There are, indeed, problems with the administration of ECT, especially in a country like India with its poor health infrastructure. It would be foolish to deny that the practice is subject to abuse (as Solomon and numerous Indian writers report). The continued use of direct ECT (without the use of an anesthetic) is certainly a matter of concern and a concerted effort to implement national guidelines making modified ECT (using an anesthetic) mandatory is as necessary as it is laudatory. But we can all do without more pieces of journalism which perpetuate the myth that ECT is a medically unjustified, indeed barbaric practice, tantamount to torture. This ignorant view, equally prevalent in the West as it is in India, has more to do with movies like One Flew Over The Cuckoos Nest than with scientific fact.

“The article Shock therapy for mental patients will be reviewed continues the ignorant tradition of demonizing electroconvulsive therapy (ECT)” - this is a GMAT reading comprehension passage with answers. Candidates need a strong knowledge of English GMAT reading comprehension.

This GMAT Reading Comprehension consists of 3 comprehension questions. The GMAT Reading Comprehension questions tests the ability of the candidate in understanding, analyzing, and applying information or concepts. Candidates can actively prepare with the help of GMAT Reading Comprehension Practice Questions.

Solution and Explanation

1. It can be inferred that the author believes that the author of the article mentioned in the first line

1. fails to question her source material rigorously
2. includes unwarranted matter
3. uses an excess of pejorative terms

1. I only
2. I and II only
3. I and III only
4. III only
5. I, II and III

2. The author's attitude towards ECT is best described as a

1. determined neutrality
2. mild criticism
3. wholehearted approbation
4. qualified approval
5. laudatory justification

3. The authors makes his point primarily by

1. offering a particular authority as a counterview
2. attacking one authors lack of social responsibility
3. criticizing the mindset of medical journalists
4. a reasoned discussion of the merits and demerits of a therapy
5. offering an objective evaluation

Suggested GMAT Reading Comprehension Samples

• Historians have Identified Two Dominant Currents in the Russian Women's Movement of the Late Tsarist Period.
• Some Historians Contend that Conditions in the United States During the Second World War
• Comparable Worth, as a Standard Applied to Eliminate Inequities in Pay
• Conventional Wisdom has it that Large Deficits in the United States Budget Cause Interest Rates to Rise.
• A One-Child Policy was Implemented in China in 1979
• The Pioneers of the Teaching of Science Imagined that its Introduction into Education would Remove the Conventionality, Artificiality, and Backward-Lookingness
• A Fundamental Principle of Pharmacology is that all Drugs have Multiple Actions. Actions that are Desirable in the Treatment of Disease are Considered therapeutic
• In the 1980's, Astronomer Bohdan Paczynski Proposed a Way of Determining Whether the Enormous Dark Halo Constituting the Outermost Part of the Milky Way Galaxy
• Solar Ponds are Bodies of Water in Which Circulation is Incomplete and There is a Very High Salt Concentration that Increases with Depth
• Even More Than Mountainside Slides of Mud or Snow, Naturally Occurring Forest Fires Promote the Survival of Aspen Trees.
• The Black Death, a Severe Epidemic that Ravaged Fourteenth Century Europe
• The System of Patent-Granting, Which Confers Temporary Monopolies for the Exploitation of New Technologies
• The United States Government has a Long-Standing Policy of Using Federal Funds to Keep Small Business Viable.
• A Recent Study has Provided Clues to Predator-Prey Dynamics in the Late Pleistocene Era.
• Ethnohistoric Documents from Sixteenth-Century Mexico Suggesting that Weaving and Cooking were the Most Common Productive Activities for Aztec Women
• Traditional Social Science Models of Class Groups in the United States are Based on Economic Status
• The General Density Dependence Model can be Applied to Explain the Founding of Specialist Firms
• Many People Believe that Wages are Lower in Developing Countries than in Developed Countries
• More Selective than Most Chemical Pesticides in that they Ordinarily Destroy only Unwanted Species
• Citing the Fact that the Real Gross Domestic Product (GDP) per capita was Higher in 1997