If -2 < a < 11 and 3 < b < 12, Then Which of the Following is NOT Always True GMAT Problem Solving

Question: If -2 < a < 11 and 3 < b < 12, then which of the following is NOT always true?

  1. 1 < a + b < 23
  2. -14 < a - b < 8
  3. -7 < b - a < 14
  4. 1 < b + a < 23
  5. -24 < a b < 132

Correct Answer: C
Solution and Explanation:
Approach Solution 1:

a+b…
For range, take max values of both for upper end and min values for lower end.
upper end : 11+12=23 & lower end : -2+3=1.... So  1 < a + b < 11
A & D are correct

a-b…
For range, take max value of a and min value of b for upper end and min value of a and max value of b for lower end.
upper end : 11-3=8 & lower end : -2-12=-14.... So  -14 < a – b < 8

B is correct

b-a.
For range, take min value of a and max value of b for upper end and max value of a and min value of b for lower end.
upper end : 12-(-2)=14 & lower end : 3-11=-8.... So -8 < b – a < 14 but given is  -7 < b – a < 14
C is Not correct

ab…
For range, take max value of a and max value of b for upper end and min value of a and max value of b for lower end.
upper end : 11*12=132 & lower end : -2*12=-24... So  -24 < ab < 132
E is correct ..

Approach Solution 2:
We have a range of a: -2 < a < 11. This means range of -a: -11 < -a < 2
We have a range of b: 3 < b < 12. This means range of -b: -12 < -b < -3

Now, the range of (a+b) or (b+a): (-2+3) < a+b < (11+12) Or 1 < a+b < 23.
So A and D are true.

Range of a-b is range of a+(-b): (-2-12) < a-b < (11-3) Or -14 < a-b < 8
So B is also true

Range of b-a is range of b+(-a): (3-11) < b-a < (12+2) Or -8 < b-a < 14
As we can see, C is not always true

Approach Solution 3:
If we add the two inequalities together, we have:

1 < a + b < 23

Thus, A is true and since a + b = b + a, D is also true.

Multiplying the second inequality by -1, we have 3 > -b > -12 or -12 < -b < 3. Now, adding the latter to the first inequality, we have:

–14 < a – b < 8

So B is true.

Similarly, multiplying the first inequality by -1, we have 2 > -a > -11 or -11 < -a < 2. Now. adding the latter to the second inequality, we have:

–8 < b – a < 14

So C is NOT true since (b - a) could be -7.5, which does not fall into -7 < b - a < 14.

“If -2 < a < 11 and 3 < b < 12, then which of the following is NOT always true?”- is a topic of the GMAT Quantitative reasoning section of GMAT. To solve GMAT Problem Solving questions a student must have knowledge about a good amount of qualitative skills. GMAT Quant practice papers improve the mathematical knowledge of the candidates as it represents multiple sorts of quantitative problems.

Suggested GMAT Problem Solving Questions

Fees Structure

CategoryState
General15556

In case of any inaccuracy, Notify Us! 

Comments


No Comments To Show