My friend is currently pursuing B.Tech from NIT Raipur in the mechanical department. His honest opinion says that you should go for metallurgy at NIT Trichy. Here’s why
So, if you simply want to get into a better place then choose NIT Trichy. This is because you can get the advantage of branch sliding anyhow. However, if you don’t want to take risk of not getting the desired branch, then go for NIT Raipur.
At last, sort your preferences and know your sole aim. Because in the long run, your happiness and satisfaction are what matters the most!
Surely, Metallurgy at PEC over Mechanical in UIET. There are various important reasons behind this: Placements in PEC are better, companies like Google, Amazon, Microsoft, etc. visit campus for placements.
Though metallurgy has fewer placements than other branches in PEC, once you are in PEC and if you are focused enough, you can go for an upgrade after 1st semester on the basis of CGPA. To aim for it, keep the following things in mind -
Categories |
Mechanical Engineering at UIET Chandigarh |
Metallurgy at PEC Chandigarh |
Course Fee |
82197 (1st year) |
6.39 lakh |
Highest CTC |
12.5 LPA |
17.75 LPA |
Average CTC |
3.6 LPA |
7.5 LPA |
Recruiting Companies |
Saint Gobain, ZS Associates, Honeywell, Tata, etc. |
ZS Associates, Amazon, JP Morgan, JSW Steels, etc. |
PEC is far superior to UIET in terms of cultural and other extracurricular activities. If you don't have any branch priorities, I'd recommend metallurgy in PEC.
My brother had the option of VIT for CSE on merit still he chose PEC metallurgy. There are various reasons as to why he took that decision:
Categories |
ECE at VIT Vellore |
Metallurgy at PEC Chandigarh |
Course Fee |
7.83 lakh |
6.39 lakh |
Highest CTC |
21 LPA |
17.75 LPA |
Average CTC |
9.3 LPA |
7.5 LPA |
Recruiting Companies |
Deloitte, Bank of America, IBM, HCL, etc. |
ZS Associates, Amazon, JP Morgan, JSW Steels, etc. |
I personally believe VIT is overrated because a friend who did not even pass mains received 2000 AIR in VITEEE. In the CBSE 2016 boards, he scored 78 percent, which was below average.
It depends upon your expectations, your goals, your abilities, etc. The worth of doing Material Sciences and Metallurgy Engineering at PEC Chandigarh will depend on the following factor:
Categories |
Metallurgical and Materials Engineering at PEC Chandigarh |
Course Fee |
6.39 lakh |
Highest CTC |
17.75 LPA |
Average CTC |
6-7 LPA |
Recruiting Companies |
ZS Associates, Wipro, Capgemini, JP Morgan, etc. |
PEC Chandigarh is not a bad college and has a legacy of close to 100 years now. It is also ranked 68 in the NIRF 2020 engineering college rankings. Take a decision based on what you want rather than superficial stats and other things.
I have friends studying production engineering at PEC Chandigarh and they have come across that it is somewhat similar to mechanical engineering. You can expect a lot of mechanics and physics, however, some subjects differ as you get into the core.
Coming to the question, it totally depends on your pool of interest whether you are into mechanics and production or metallurgy. Here are two major factors you might consider before choosing any of them
At the end of the day, follow your passion and know where you can invest these 4 years of your life. Nevertheless, if getting a job is your goal then go for production engineering. On the other hand, metallurgy engineering can open doors for good research work if you are interested in doing so.
Always pursue what you are interested in because if you love to do something in a field particularly, you will definitely achieve heights. Since I have a few friends at PEC, I can give you some idea about the Metallurgy course offered there.
PEC-Metallurgy:
Here’s a brief comparison of the institutes.
Parameters |
PEC Chandigarh |
Pantnagar University |
Average CTC |
10.2 LPA |
7 LPA |
Highest CTC |
42 LPA |
11 LPA |
Course Fee |
3.45 lakhs |
2.31 lakhs |
Now, if you want to do research or want good placements, don’t even think about Pantnagar.
Considering the opportunities which may get available for you in the future, I would suggest you go for Chemical Engineering at NIT Surat as it would be a better option over metallurgy. As my sister studied there, I am very well aware of the college and its pros and cons.
Categories |
Chemical at NIT Surat |
Metallurgy at NIT Surathkal |
Course Fee |
5.63 lakh |
5.45 lakh |
Highest CTC |
16 LPA |
12 LPA |
Average CTC |
7 LPA |
6 LPA |
Recruiting Companies |
ONGC, DE Shaw, GlaxoSmithKline, Hindustan Unilever, etc. |
Tata Steel, Ambuja Cement, Tech Mahindra, Vedanta, etc. |
Choose wisely after performing a significant amount of research and analysis about the courses that you wish to get enrolled in from either of these institutions.
If you are interested in CSE and have the confidence that you will be able to get IITs/NITs/BITS, you can take a drop year. But this option has its risks. PEC Chandigarh offers branch sliding options. Although the cutoff requirement is high for CSE, it's certainly doable with hard work. This way you won’t have to worry about a drop year.
Having friends studying in both the colleges, It is suggested that you go for NIT Jamshedpur metallurgy would prove to be a better option because the placement records of the college are pretty good.
Categories |
NIT Jamshedpur |
IIEST Shibpur |
Fees |
7.16 lakh |
1.36 lakh |
Lowest CTC |
3 LPA |
2.53 LPA |
Highest CTC |
30 LPA |
40 LPA |
Both colleges are good in their own ways. They can also be considered a good option for your education only after good research is being made in regard to your requirements. Ultimately it is your choice, but due to its locational advantage, I will suggest you go for NIT Jamshedpur.
NIT Trichy would be a better choice than IIT Bhubaneswar for Metallurgy because of the following reasons.