IIT Dhanbad faces little competition from other colleges in mining, making it the best mining campus in the country, but the branch itself is very challenging, and the career prospects are very different from what you might be thinking of after graduation.
NIT Surathkal is very comparable to IIT Dhanbad and CSE and will open many doors for you and provide better placement opportunities. You should not choose mining over CSE at NIT Surathkal unless you have a genuine interest in mining or a background in mining.
IIT Dhanbad is one of the oldest institutions to offer a degree program in Mining. The program is nearly 90 years old and has the most experienced faculty members. IIT Bhilai on the other hand is a fairly new institute.
Here is a brief overview of the two branches mentioned in the question.
Particulars |
IIT Dhanbad Mining |
IIT Bhilai Mechanical |
Average CTC |
10 LPA |
11.2 LPA |
Course Fee |
8.88 lakhs |
8.95 lakhs |
Advantages - Mining IIT Dhanbad:
Placements: (Winning Institution - IIT Dhanbad)
The Mining branch has a great placement record at IIT Dhanbad.
Therefore, based on the given institutions IIT Dhanbad for Mining is the better alternative.
The mining branch in IIT BHU is one of the ancillary branches(along with ceramics and Pharmaceutical Engineering) which most students often refrain from. Students often opt for the branch just with the hope of getting a better branch through branch change. Besides, the curriculum is very tough and it requires a humongous effort to get a decent CGPA in the mining branch.
Also, the branch doesn’t attract noteworthy companies for placements. Students are thus left with the sole option of getting acquainted with the coding culture for securing placements. Furthermore, the branch of Mining Engineering in India is not fully in consonance with the curriculum taught in foreign universities. However, it is pertinent to note that the branch does have considerable scope in many Coal and Mining companies.
So, if you have a profound interest in the branch, only then you should opt for it in IIT BHU Mining. Don’t just go for the IIT tag and choose a branch that offers ample opportunities, both in jobs as well as in further studies.
Indian Institute of Technology (BHU) is a public engineering university, situated in Varanasi. The institute has tie-ups with the University of Cambridge (UK), University of Oxford (UK), University of Sheffield (UK). IIT BHU has been ranked 10th and 11th in the categories engineering and overall by the NIRF rankings in 2019.
Course details
Admission Procedure
Facilities
Placements
IIT BHU provides top-class infrastructure and facilities, with the availability of laboratories which make the course curriculum industry-driven. Students are given an enriched learning experience and are given hands-on experience through internships. The placement scenario of the course is also very good, with students landing great placements. Students with interest in the subject should opt for the course at IIT BHU.
IIEST Shibpurholds rank #21 in India by NIRF Rankings in 2020. Admission is based on the rank scored inJEE Mainand for the M.Tech courses, admission is based onGATE results. The total course fee is around 5.48 lakhs with a total of 30 seats.
Admission process
Placements
The institute offers world-class facilities to students to provide them with great exposure to the industry. Faculty are highly qualified and have great experience in their respective fields.
NIT Durgapur and IIEST Shibpur both are excellent universities for pursuing Bachelor's and Master's in Engineering. Both institutes are located in different parts of West Bengal in famous areas. NIT Durgapur has been ranked and 46th in Engineering Category by the NIRF Rankings in India. It does carry a reputation value to the degree by being a premier institute of Engineering. IIEST is a lesser-known institute but well advanced in their research faculty and content.
In a nutshell:
Colleges |
Admission |
Placements |
Tuition fee |
NIT Durgapur |
JEE Main |
70% |
1,49,100 |
IIEST Shibpur |
JEE Main |
Metallurgy: 68.6% Mining: 80.1% |
1,37,000 |
Courses:
Admission:
Admission at NIT would be much more competitive than IIEST. It requires a higher JEE mains rank. The choice of the subject involves even more competitiveness as it is done at the end of the first year based on CGPA. Most students who get selected at NIT do not wish to go for metallurgy, however, if you are interested, then it is one of the best institutes. IIEST is relatively easy when it comes to admissions and choice of subjects.
Placements:
The B.Tech. program at IIEST may not hold much value, but it is supplemented by excellent research professors who encourage students to take part in national missions and research projects. The competitiveness at NIT won’t provide that opportunity to every student.
Indian Institute of Engineering Science and Technology Shibpur (IIEST Shibpur) is the second oldest engineering college in India. It offers 45 courses in Engineering, Management, Science, and Architecture. Admissions are conducted through central exams conducted by UGC like JEE, XAM, etc. IIEST has over 250 faculty members including regular guest faculty. It hosts 4000 students every year for their higher education. Even though the institute is engaged in a number of fields, it is most famous for its B.Tech and M.Tech course of Engineering.
Civil Engineering Department:
The Department of Civil Engineering is one of the oldest departments at IIEST Shibpur. The Civil Engineering course mainly deals with Structural engineering, geotechnical engineering, water resource engineering, environmental engineering, and transportation engineering.
Mining Engineering Department:
The Department of Mining Engineering at IIEST, Shibpur was the pioneer in imparting Mining Engineering education in the country. Today, it stands as one of the most diverse and vibrant departments encompassing all disciplines within Mining Engineering and associates areas.
Opportunities:
Courses and Duration:
Faculty:
The table given below gives a brief overview of both the institutes:
Course |
Admission Cut off |
Fees |
Placements |
Degrees Offered |
Civil Engineering |
19147 - 27598 |
1,36,000 |
57.14% |
B.Tech, M.Tech, P.hD |
Mining Engineering |
22516 - 31923 |
1,36,000 |
81.48% |
A dual degree, M.Tech, P.hD |
Thus it depends entirely upon the student and their interest in Civil or Mechanical Engineering that will help them choose a course. While it is important to mark these differences, any course or college can be the best for the student if he/she knows how to utilize the opportunity completely.
The placements in Mining are moderate with a decent number of students securing placements.
Categories |
Mining at IIEST Shibpur |
Course Fee |
1.55 L-1.94 lakh |
Placement Percentage |
85% |
Highest CTC |
14 LPA |
Average CTC |
7 LPA |
Lowest CTC |
4 LPA |
Recruiting Companies |
Tata Steel, Vedanta Resources Limited, Hindalco, Gainwell, DMT, Zycus, Infosys, etc. |
Even though it is the responsibility of the individual to decide as per what they want to opt for, yet in terms of statistics for a particular year is as briefed below:
The Mining Department of IIEST, Shibpur is nominated by the Government of India as one of the Govt. Agencies, mainly out of five, for verification of Mine Closure Activity. The institute has been the first DST FIST sponsored department as well.
No particular brand is better than the other as it all depends on your own preference and inclinations. One needs to stop thinking that mechanical is the most demanded branch. In my opinion, every branch is important and has the scope to attract people who are passionate about it. Hence it is illogical to say that one branch is superior to another.
I suggest you go for a branch not because it has scope but because you are genuinely interested in that branch and are ready to pursue a career in it. For instance, my brother chose mechanical engineering not because he thought it had a higher scope than mining, but because my father himself is a mechanical engineer and he wanted to continue the legacy.
Rather than following the sheep mentality and choosing a certain branch, you can refer to the following options