Being part of a cohort with a wide range of prior job experience is advantageous because of the invaluable lessons that may be learned from one's peers. A new student will bring enthusiasm, energy, and fresh ideas to the table; a more seasoned student will check to make sure everything has been thought of, practice effective situation management, and disseminate knowledge gained on the job. I am not suggesting that one individual is incapable of doing each task; a smart and reflective newcomer can show remarkable situational awareness and the capacity to account for important factors.
When it comes to internships and full-time jobs, the conventional wisdom holds that recent college grads have an advantage over those with previous work experience because they are easier to mold. Similarly, companies hire for the long term and focus on finding the greatest fit student during internships and final placements.
In addition to that, there is nothing like giving more preference to work experience guys. It must have been a situation as the current year students with work ex performed well in the interview process to convert IMT Ghaziabad.
IMT Ghaziabad is in a different league as of now. Though TAPMI is improving, It's still behind IMT G. In this scenario, the institute matters, not your specialization.
In my limited experience working in the sector and with recruiters, IMT has a better reputation than TAPMI. In many organizations, IMT is a better B-school than TAPMI. It's about image. As your career progresses, that is more significant than campus placements.
IMT is relaxed and requires self-motivation. You have every chance-use it. IMT has a great faculty, so you should be fine.
Particulars |
TAPMI Manipal |
IMT Ghaziabad |
Highest Package |
INR 22.3 LPA |
INR 65.6 LPA |
Average Package |
INR 15.7 LPA |
INR 17.35 LPA |
Fees |
INR 15.50 LPA |
INR 19.53 LPA |
Undoubtedly, IMT G is a better option than TAPMI.
My senior from school was a student of IMT Ghaziabad and this is what she said when I asked her the same question.
In the field of management education, XIMB (BM) and IMT Ghaziabad are somewhat competitors. Both institutes boast of an excellent environment for learning, both are renowned, both have enviable faculty and placement records. So, if you want to join either college, you can almost guarantee yourself a bright future.
However, if you want to pursue MBA or PGDM in Marketing, then IMT Ghaziabad will be superior to XIBM (BM). Conferences and seminars are conducted by the institute for providing the best education with a practical approach. IMT Ghaziabad was way ahead as per the latest placement reports. In the pre-campus placements, over 150 leading companies took part in offering lucrative packages to the candidates. Some of them even got employment opportunities overseas. 58.22 LPA was the higher package.
So, if you are planning on taking a Marketing specialization, you can’t go wrong with IMT Ghaziabad.
IMT Ghaziabad can be considered among the top innovative B-schools in India. One of my cousins is part of the institute and as per him, there is no management quota or backdoor entry for the PGDM course.
The only possible way to enroll at IMT Ghaziabad is to achieve the required scores in CAT, CMAT, and CET.
Earlier in IMT Ghaziabad, there were candidates who neither scored well nor qualified for the entrance criteria. Despite these major drawbacks in their academic backdrop, it was not clear what caused their admission at IMT Ghaziabad. The entry belongs entirely in the hands of the top management system of the institute. It can often play a role, but only infrequently, given the situation.
In fewer words, it may or may not happen because nobody still has a concrete idea. However, it is best that you stay updated with any information that you acquire of this situation and interpret on your own. Hope this helps answer your query, wish you all the best!
I would say, SP Jain. If you want to go into Marketing, Operations, and Supply Chain, you should go for it. If you want to go into core marketing, you can go to IMT Ghaziabad.
Both are good schools, but if you just look at the rankings, SPJIMR is in the top 10 in India, while IMT is in the top 40. That’s a huge difference.
SPJIMR gets more companies than IMT Ghaziabad. SPJIMR is also the first when it comes to ranking.
Parameters |
SP Jain |
IMT Ghaziabad |
Average Package |
INR 33.02 LPA |
INR 15.28 LPA |
Highest Package |
INR 77.8 LPA |
INR 34 LPA |
Median Package |
INR 32.89 LPA |
INR 16 LPA |
Fees |
20.42 Lakhs |
19.53 Lakhs |
It all depends on what you are looking for, your goals, and your preferences. IMT Ghaziabad (Estd. 1980) is an old legacy institute while the baby IIMs (Estd. 2015) (although it is offensive to call them that) are relatively new. Below is a table comparing their absolute numbers like Fees, Highest salary package, and the average salary package.
College |
Fees |
Highest CTC |
Average CTC |
IMT Ghaziabad |
INR 19.53 Lakhs |
INR 65.6 LPA |
INR 17.35 LPA |
IIM Nagpur |
INR 18 Lakhs |
INR 64 LPA |
INR 16.74 LPA |
IIM Amritsar |
INR 16 Lakhs |
INR 64 LPA |
INR 16.51 LPA |
IIM Visakhapatnam |
INR 17.04 Lakhs |
INR 32.65 LPA |
INR 16.61 LPA |
As you can see there is not much difference in the colleges in absolute numbers the only difference is the IIM tag.
There is a good track record of placements at IMT Ghaziabad, as the 2023 placement season has broken past records. Students from IMT Ghaziabad have received attractive salary packages not only in the domestic market but also in the international market. The highest international package received by a student is cited as 65.60 lakhs per annum, which is quite significant. Additionally, the highest domestic package received is stated as 34 lakhs per annum, indicating that there are good opportunities available for students in the domestic market as well.
Total number of companies that visited the campus |
150+ |
Highest domestic salary offered |
34 lakhs per annum |
Average domestic salary offered |
14.23 lakhs per annum |
Highest international salary offered |
65.6 lakhs per annum |
Median salary offered |
16.0 lakhs per annum |
No, I don't think the new IIMs should be preferred over a well-established institute like IMT Ghaziabad. I have seen many instances wherein people forgo offers from new IIMs to join IMT Ghaziabad.
The IIM brand has failed to convince students to join the new IIMs for a diploma. A cursory glance at the low placement figures last year at some of the relatively newer IIMs (Raipur, Rohtak, Ranchi, Kashipur, and Udaipur) when compared to their older counterparts, too, tells its own story.
Another important issue for management aspirants is that even if they are okay with the lack of infrastructure, full-time faculty members, and alumni, they cannot ignore the delayed start to the sessions at the new IIMs. While faculty members think that this time gap in starting operations can be bridged easily, students feel that they might lose out on their summer internships.
Both XIMB and IMT Ghaziabad are very good colleges but XIMB will be a better choice than IMT Ghaziabad. I know some people from both the institute, so I think I can give you some insight about them.
Here are some recent statistics regarding the institutes.
Parameters |
XIMB |
IMT Ghaziabad |
Average CTC |
15 LPA |
10-15 LPA |
Highest CTC |
24 LPA |
38 LPA |
Hence, choosing XIMB will be a better choice as it is a very reputed college and the academics and faculty here are very good too. But if you are looking for diversity in your batch then you should choose IMT.
The pedagogy followed at IMT Ghaziabad is considered to be good and it is a reputable institution for those considering a career in marketing. In comparison to many of the newer IIMs and other B-Schools in India, IMT Ghaziabad is known to have a strong faculty, regular campus visits from companies, and a variety of competitions and events to enhance the student experience.
The PGDBM program at IMT Ghaziabad, as well as many other B-Schools in India, follows a standardized curriculum and method of testing students' theoretical knowledge. The program is typically divided into six or seven terms, and students are required to complete a summer internship and submit a final report before graduation. The experience of students at IMT Ghaziabad should not be considered significantly different from those of students graduating from other B-Schools.