If you're trying to decide between XIMB BM and IMT Ghaziabad, you might find it helpful to know that while both programs are reputable, XIMB BM has a slight edge. However, keep in mind that this difference may not be significant enough to base your decision on.
That being said, if you're set on choosing between these two programs, XIMB BM would be the way to go. However, if you're open to exploring other options, it might be worth considering furthering your profile and aiming for even higher-ranked programs.
Improving your profile could include gaining more work experience, pursuing additional education or certifications, or getting involved in extracurricular activities related to your desired field. By doing so, you can increase your chances of getting accepted into more prestigious MBA programs, which can lead to greater career opportunities and earning potential.
Ultimately, the decision of which MBA program to choose is a personal one that should be based on your individual goals and circumstances. Take the time to research and consider all of your options before making a decision, and don't be afraid to seek advice from mentors or professionals in your desired field.
If you had to choose from the options mentioned, it's recommended to opt for a brand name. Your priority should be IMT Ghaziabad, IMI Delhi, and SIOM Nashik.
When it comes to Operations Management, NITIE, and IITs are considered to be top-notch. They offer a comprehensive curriculum, job roles, and industry exposure, making them highly sought-after. In fact, IITs have established their brand in management, specifically due to their expertise in operations. However, when it comes to Operation major, NITIE remains unparalleled, as they have the longest chain of alumni in operations, holding high-level designations for many years.
If operations are still your preferred field, and you don't have any other options apart from NITIE or IITs, then your decision should be entirely based on the brand you are joining.
Before I talk about the worth of private B Schools like IMT/IMI/XIMB, let’s consider their average packages.
B School |
Average Package |
IMT |
INR 17.35 LPA |
IMI Delhi |
INR 17.01 LPA |
XIMB |
INR 20 LPA |
The average package of government colleges like IITs and DSE is slightly less around INR 10.57 LPA. So the point is if you are ready to invest a hefty amount in B Schools, you will not regret the decision as they are game changers. The level of exposure and diversity is almost higher than in Government colleges. IITs, DFS and DSE MBAs have a more theoretical approach than a practical one. However, the figures for private B schools are inflated so do consider the ups and downs.
The final decision is up to you. Try to find what exactly you want from MBA
Make a well-informed decision after proper research.
If you have a closer look, there is no major difference between the 3 B Schools. So I have made it easier by judging them on the basis of 2 parameters only.
Admissions: Most competent students get a call from 2 of these 3 institutes as all the 3 to have similar requisites
Placements: The placements are also at a similar level. The profiles and packages offered are similar in all the 3 B Schools except that IMT is a little behind owing to its huge batch size.
So I would say the order would be as this- XIMB >=IMI>IMT
The table below will give you a better picture of the comparison between the 3 colleges
Particulars |
XIMB |
IMI |
IMT |
Batch size |
364 |
308 |
500 |
Fees |
?20 Lakhs (MBA) |
?18.17 L |
INR 6 L - 19.02 L (for 18 months-3 years) |
Number of recruiters |
64 |
100+ |
130+ |
Highest salary |
INR 32.21 LPA |
INR 50 LPA |
INR 62 LPA |
Average salary |
INR 17.54 LPA |
INR 17.01 LPA |
INR 15.28 LPA |
Top sector |
Consulting (46%), IT/ITES (22%) |
Consulting/ EdTech |
IT/ITES |
Top Recruiters |
ICICI Bank, Accenture, Cognizant |
ICICI Bank, Deloitte, Accenture, Infosys, KPMG |
Morgan Stanley, BCG, Accenture Consulting, Goldman Sachs, Google, Infosys Consulting, Emami International, TATA Consumer Product |
To secure admission to top MBA institutes in India, you should aim for CAT percentiles from 85 onwards. Here's the order of the institutes you should target in descending order - IIM K with 97+ percentile, MDI with 96+, IMT Ghaziabad with 90+, SPJain with 85+, and NITIE with as high as possible sectional-wise.
Even though SPJain is a premier institute, it gives a call from the 85 percentile onward, since they focus on overall values that an individual possesses and want students with more values in them. They have 2 group interviews, so they follow a rejection procedure.
NITIE has a sectional cutoff, so it's advisable to have as high as possible sectional-wise, as many people with an overall CAT percentile in the range of 97-98 were not selected in either of their 2 programs(PGDM and PGDIESM) in 2016.
IIM K also has a sectional cutoff of 90+, so it's important to score well in each section.
It's worth noting that these institutes do not have a sectional cutoff, but it's always advisable to have a 90+ sectional percentile to be on the safer side. Aim for high percentile and sectional scores to improve your chances of securing a seat in these prestigious institutes.
Both the options you mentioned, IMI Delhi PGDM and IMT G Finance are good in their own individual aspects. So you should rather be asking which is better for you. Now this depends on what you really want from your PGDM. By choosing PGDM Finance you will limit yourself only to the Finance sector, whereas a PGDM core will give you a chance to explore various domains before selecting your specialization. The former is a good option if you are certain about your interest in Finance and want to excel in that sector no matter what while the latter is good if you are open to all options.
Talking about IMI Delhi in general, the B School offers an abundance of opportunities through student bodies and other student driven activities. Moreover the additional locational advantage is what makes it a fairly good option. The batch size is also not too big and thus balances the student teacher ratio.
Placements are pretty decent at IMI Delhi. The IMI Delhi average package (overall) offered during 2023 placements was INR 17.01 LPA. For PGDM, PGDM (B&FS), and PGDM (HR) the average package stood at INR 17.20 LPA, INR 16.48 LPA, and INR 15.58 LPA, respectively.
The primary highlight of the B School is its student exchange program wherein students from foreign universities join the B School for a fixed period while students from IMI Delhi visit a foreign university in exchange.
All these factors make IMI Delhi a very good choice in comparison to IMT G.
In choosing your B-school, the primary factors that you should consider are, the specialization you want to opt for and the ROI you are expecting. In your case, you want to go for Finance. The list of preferred B Schools you mentioned has similar fees and placements so I will be answering solely based on specialization.
Finance: IMI Delhi is the best choice of all the options when it comes to Finance. A premium quality crowd opts for Finance at IMI Delhi and the main reason is the customized MBA program in Finance. Many companies of the Finance sector visit the campus for placements. Finance students also avail the best opportunities and guidance and have a higher level of security than Marketing students.
However, in case you have more than 2-3 years of work experience, IMI Delhi is not a suitable option. Although you may stand out among your batchmates, the companies visiting the campus are not aware of this and offer roles suitable for less experienced students only. So your work experience may not be credited here.
The general preference order should be: IMI D>XIMB>IMT G
When considering MBA programs, it is important to recognize that not all institutions are created equal. Some institutions often referred to as "legacy institutions," have a long history of success and are widely recognized as some of the best business schools in the country. Other institutions, often referred to as "baby IIMs," are relatively new and may not yet have the same level of prestige or reputation as legacy institutions.
However, when it comes to choosing a business school, it's important not to compare legacy institutions and baby IIMs directly, as each has its own strengths and weaknesses. Instead, it is recommended to focus on the specific institution and the attributes it brings. One such institution is IMT Ghaziabad, which is a well-established institution that is known for its academic programs and reputation in the industry.
It's important to note that MBA aspirations can differ from person to person and it's essential to identify what the MBA means for you. There are two types of MBA aspirants:
It is highly recommended to decide by yourself, Among which category you belong, and then go for it. According to the opinion stated in the passage, the recommendation is towards the category of legacy institutions.
Leaving a job with such good pay is a very risky decision and should be considered only if it’s the top B School you are after. These include the top IIMS, XLRI, FMS, SP JAIN, or MDI. Giving up your high-paying job to join IMT Ghaziabad does not make sense. The ROI will not be worth the program considering the two-year opportunity loss of salary and high IMT fees.
Moreover, IMT Ghaziabad placements are quite restricted in the sense that if you are not among the top 100 students in a batch of 600 students, you will end up with an average package only. The companies visiting IMT Ghaziabad offer the MT position usually to freshers and not students with work experience. Considering all this I don’t think leaving your job for an MBA from IMT Ghaziabad is a wise decision.
The distance MBA aims at promoting easy-to-access education without interrupting your work and personal life. The colleges you mentioned NMIMS, IMT Ghaziabad, Symbiosis, or even IGNOU are all good but for distance learning Chandigarh University is the best option. With Chandigarh University’s Distance Education and Open Learning program, you can learn from a variety of Industry relevant, well-organized learner-centric programs with placement support. This program is most suitable for those who are on the lookout for quality education but have locational issues. Some major highlights of the distance MBA course from Chandigarh University are
Eligibility: The eligibility criteria for distance MBA at Chandigarh University is
Duration: 2 years (minimum)
Specialization: The Distance MBA offers the following specializations
Fees: The fees structure is as follows
Particulars |
Odd Semester |
Even Semester |
Academic Fee |
INR 9950 |
INR 9950 |
Registration Fee |
INR 2500 |
- |
Exam Fee |
INR 2000 |
INR 2000 |