Some colleges like ISB, BITS Pilani, XLRI, SPJAIN, etc. do not have a caste-based reservation. Is it not mandatory for all colleges in India?

Answer
Share
More
2 Answers

PD
Pratim Dasgupta Posted On - Apr 22, 2023
PGDM HRM, Xavier School of Management

Caste-based reservations in higher education institutions are mandated by the Constitution of India, specifically under Articles 15(4) and 16(4). These articles allow for the reservation of seats in educational institutions for students belonging to Scheduled Castes (SCs), Scheduled Tribes (STs), and Other Backward Classes (OBCs), who have historically been marginalized and disadvantaged in Indian society.

However, it's important to note that private institutions, such as ISB, BITS Pilani, XLRI, SPJAIN, etc., are not required to provide caste-based reservations. These institutions have the autonomy to decide their own admission policies, including the reservation policies they choose to implement.

In recent years, there has been some debate about whether or not private institutions should also be required to provide caste-based reservation, but no concrete policy changes have been made at the national level as of yet. Some states, such as Maharashtra, have mandated caste-based reservations in private educational institutions through state-level policies, but this is not yet a nationwide trend.

It's worth noting that even private institutions that don't have caste-based reservations may still have other forms of affirmative action policies or scholarships for disadvantaged students, including those from SC/ST/OBC backgrounds. Ultimately, the admission policies of each institution will depend on their individual values and priorities.

0
0
Share
Comments

Comments


No Comments To Show
GJ
Gurpreet Jain Posted On - May 25, 2021
PhD from Birla Institute of Technology and Science, Pilani (2016)

BITS Pilani is affiliated with the UGC which is why a caste-based reservation is required for the enrollment of students. It also has received funding in the form of Science and Technology Projects (UGC Major and Minor Projects). 

As for now, the funding released for BITS has been stopped by the UGC, and BITS Pilani does not receive any financial support from any of the government authorities. But, BITS Pilani does not follow the criterion of selecting students based on caste-based reservations. A case has been filed against BITS for the same reason. 

A major reason why these Institutes refuse to follow the reservation-based criterion because they are Private and do not receive any funding from the Government authorities. Due to privatization, reservation rules are not mandatory for these institutes. 

These Institutes can follow any criterion for their selection process based on their choices. No Government body has the authority to force these institutes to follow and include a caste-based reservation in their system.

0
0
Share
Comments

Comments


No Comments To Show