MDI Murshidabad is a better option among the two, with the brand name of MDI Gurgaon benefitting Murshidabad as well. The placement stats of both colleges are given below
MDI Murshidabad-
Year |
2023 |
2022 |
2021 |
Highest package |
INR 20 LPA |
INR 22 LPA |
INR 26.42 LPA |
Average package |
INR 12.67 LPA |
INR 11.32 LPA |
INR 10.5 LPA |
PUMBA-
Year |
2020 |
2021 |
Highest Package |
INR 18 LPA |
INR 13.55 LPA |
Average Package |
INR 7.6 LPA |
INR 6.47 LPA |
Given the above information provided, MDI Murshidabad is the better choice.
Candidates who are allotted seats by the Directorate of Technical Education (DTE) need to confirm their admission at the Department of Management Sciences (PUMBA) by submitting their original documents and paying the fees during CAP Round 1 & 2, as per the specified dates by DTE. Seat allotment is done based on ranking or percentiles obtained in CET exams through CAP Rounds 1, 2, and 3.
It is important to note that only after being selected through CAP rounds, candidates become eligible for admission to PUMBA. There are no management quota seats available in PUMBA as it is a government department and one of India's premier business schools, which operates autonomously under Savitribai Phule Pune University.
First of all, congrats on that percentile. Since the cutoff is 98-99+ and you are from the general category, unfortunately your percentile is not enough for PUMBA. Using your CET score, you can still apply for PGDM courses in different NL Dalmia, Wellingkar, KJSIMSR Mumbai, XIMR Mumbai, and Chetana institutions.
Based on the available data and rankings, SIES is a better choice than PUMBA in terms of academic excellence, campus infrastructure, faculty, and placements. SIESCOMS is accredited by the National Board of Accreditation (NBA) and has been ranked among the top 100 B-Schools in India by NIRF (National Institutional Ranking Framework).
SIESCOMS is known for its strong industry interface and focus on research. PUMBA may not be suitable for experienced professionals, as it is said to be a place for freshers. The learning experience at PUMBA may also not be as rigorous as some of the top B-schools in India. It’s especially true if a student is looking for top-notch placements and a rigorous learning experience, which is why SIES is the better option out of the two.
Choosing PUMBA for an MBA in Finance is a decent choice. Due to the fact that this college's MBA graduates' average salary is 8.10 LPA.
During their recent placement drive, PUMBA received about 122 businesses, and their highest offer to date was 18 LPA. Their tuition fee is also a little expensive given the campus area (414 acres) and the location in Maharashtra.
If the number of available seats for admission in PUMBA remains 180 for the next academic year, then there is a very strong possibility that you might get admission into PUMBA until the 3rd CAP (Centralized Admission Process) round.
If you are a fresher, I advise you to give it another go and take the CAT, XAT, and other management tests the following year. A high CAT percentile will lead to various opportunities for you.
It can be worthwhile to wait and reapply if you are convinced that you can raise your profile during the following year and get accepted into a more prestigious MBA program that better fits your professional objectives.
On the other hand, entering PUMBA might be a good choice right now if you want to start your career early and obtain job experience. Executive MBA programs can be pursued at a later time in your career.
PUMBA has three courses to offer - full-time MBA called MBA++ (with one major and one minor specialization that's why two “+”), MBA-PBT (for students with pharma background), and MBA Executive (for working people out there).
Only an Executive MBA can be pursued while holding a job.
Eligibility for EMBA-
SIMSREE outperforms PUMBA in terms of placements, academics, and educational standards.
You can check the table added below to get an insights into SIMSREE Placements 2022:
Particulars |
Statistics (2022) |
No. of participating students |
158 |
No. of recruiters |
101 |
Highest package |
19 LPA |
Average package |
10.97 LPA |
SIMREE's MAH-CET cut-off value is greater than PUMBA's.
Round |
Maharashtra State Category |
All India Category |
MBA: Round 2 |
99.95% |
99.68% |
MBA: Round 1 |
99.95% |
99.68% |
PUMBA is a well-known B-school in India that offers a variety of specializations, including Operations Management. Its MBA program includes an Operations Management specialization course.
PUMBA's Operations Management gives students a thorough understanding of business operations such as manufacturing, logistics, supply chain management, quality control, and project management. The curriculum of the program is intended to give students a practical and academic grasp of operations management.
PUMBA has experienced faculty members with in-depth topic experts who provide students with the most recent industry insights. For hands-on study, the institute offers a well-equipped library and computer lab with numerous software tools, including SAP.
Furthermore, PUMBA maintains relationships with many companies, which allows students to participate in internships and industry projects. Students can also attend national and international events, conferences, and workshops relevant to operations management.
Overall, PUMBA is an excellent option for students interested in Operations Management since it equips students with the theoretical and practical skills essential for a successful career in the industry.