The colleges that you have mentioned are quite old and reputed, leaving behind a history of a great placement record and a bright future.
Human Resources has become a promising field in today’s time. A good HR assures that the aspects of the business they work for proves to be fulfilled along with allowing the employees their own space wherein they give importance to the clients.
Based on certain parameters, allow me to compare all the three institutes so that it gets convenient to choose the B-School of your choice.
Categories | SIBM Pune | NMIMS Mumbai | SCMHRD |
Course Fee | 17.26 lakh | 6.04 lakh | 11.94 lakh |
Highest CTC | 35 LPA | 16 LPA | 18-21 LPA |
Average CTC | 18 LPA | 8 LPA | 10 LPA |
Recruiting Companies | Crisil, HSBC, etc. | Berger, ITC, etc. | Mindtree, ICICI Bank, etc. |
My suggestion would be to consider NMAT and even SNAP so that you get a better view to choose from. Some promising prospects are indeed offered by NMIMS and SIBM-P, but I believe you should go for that particular institute which is reputed for its HR department.
In terms of ranking and brand value, SIBM Pune is better than SCMHRD. India Today 2021 has ranked SIBM Pune and SCMHRD 7th and 8th for MBA respectively. But rather than ranking and brand recognition, you should put more importance on the course you are going to pursue.
If you are planning on pursuing MBA Business Analytics, MBA HR, or MBA Infrastructure Management, then you should go for SCMHRD. For the Marketing specialization, both of these two are decent options.
NICMAR, RICS, SCMHRD, and XIMB all of these are reputed management institutes in India. NICMAR conducts NCAT and SCMHRAD conducts SNAP to take admission. Whereas, XIMB and RICS select students based on their performance in CAT/XAT/GMAT, etc.
Rankings:
NICMAR is ranked 1st amongst the top colleges in ASIA.
RICS, Amity University is one of the six Indian institutes which have made it to QS Asian University Rankings.
SCMHRD is ranked 4th state wise and city wise in 2020 by the Indian Institutional Ranking Framework (IIRF).
XIMB, Xavier University Bhubaneswar has been ranked 10th amongst All India Private B-School by IT-MDRA B-School Ranking 2019.
Placements:
Highlights of the placements at the institutes are as follows.
Criteria |
NICMAR |
RICS |
SCMHRD IM |
XIMB UMG |
Placement Percentage |
99.2 |
93 |
90 |
100 |
Highest Package (INR) |
13 LPA |
32 LPA |
15.4 LPA |
9.36 LPA |
Top Recruiters:
NICMAR: Adventz Group, Rabico Engg. & Construction, Reliance Industries Ltd, AFCONS Infrastructure Ltd, Synergy group, etc.
RICS: Turner & Townsend, AECOM, Rider Levett Bucknall, Formulaic Engineers Pvt. Ltd, GMR, and many more.
SCMHRD IM: Deloitte, Cognizant, Amazon, Vodafone, Kotak Life, Google, IBM, Cipla, Godrej, and many more.
XIMB XUB: Tractebel GKW GmbH, Recity Network Pvt. Ltd., Convexicon Software SolutionsIndia Pvt. Ltd., CURE, etc.
Facilities:
NICMAR:
It has a library with a rich collection of more than 23000 thesis, 2300+ volumes, 495 teaching notes, 13 e-resources, and 75 printed periodicals.
Other facilities like hostels, 24x7 wifi connections for computer labs and classrooms, auditorium, 3 conference halls, and outdoor sports facilities are offered.
RICS:
The institute has more than 100 faculty members and 1000+ students studying on the campus.
Classrooms with new-age teaching tools, computer labs, a library with 2 lakh+ books, periodicals, references to international and national journals, food courts, and cafeteria are the facilities offered by the institute.
SCMHRD:
Scholarships are offered only to students of MBA who top the first semester A total of 50% tuition fee waiver is covered by the scholarship.
The institute has a health center with specialized doctors, a yoga center and gymnasium, hostels, a library with a huge collection of more than 2000 audio and video files, 24000 books, and periodicals.
XIMB UGB:
Library, residential facility, medical help, sports, fitness facility, and professional audio-video studios are the facilities offered.
NICMAR, RICS, SCMHRD, and XIMB all these colleges are highly reputed and have nailed down their efficiency in terms of education, placements as well as all the factors required for the development of the student’s academics and career.
Except SIBM-Pune and SCMHRD, all SIIB, SIDTM, and SCIT colleges are the best Symbiosis business schools present in Pune. The admission process is the same for all and is based on entrance tests followed by personal interview and group discussion.
Ranking
Tabulated below gives a brief overview of both institutions:
Particulars |
SIIB |
SIDTM |
SCIT |
No. of seats |
210 |
150 |
180 |
Top recruiters |
ITC ABD, VMware, Zydex Industries, Darashaw, Accenture, Merck (MSD), HDFC Bank, Dun and Bradstreet, , BOX 8, Michael Page, Axis Bank |
Accenture, Aditya Birla Group, Airtel, Capgemini, Cognizant, CRISIL, Deloitte, HCL Technologies |
ACCENTURE, American Express, Axis Bank, Capgemini, Deloitte, Ernst & Young, EXL Services, Gartner, HCL Comnet |
Average salary |
10.60 lakhs |
11.60 lakhs |
11.1 lakhs |
Admission process
Placements
SIIB, Pune
SIDTM, Pune
SCIT, Pune
Overall all colleges of Symbiosis are equally good at their place. All business schools provide good facilities, Infrastructure of institutes are also pretty well maintained. All institutes provide 100 % placements to students. The teachers are very helpful and kind. The environment of the schools is also friendly and engaging.
Narsee Monjee Institute of Management Studies (NMIMS) institute is one of the best management universities in India. Admissions in this university are based on qualifying exams NPATand NMAT followed by personal interview and counseling.
Symbiosis Institute of Business Management (SIBM) Pune is one of the best business schools in India. Admission to this university is based on an entrance test known as Symbiosis National Aptitude Test (SNAP) followed by personal interview and group discussion.
Symbiosis Center for Management & Human Resource Development (SCMHRD) holds 13th rank for MBA issued by times. Admissions for MBA are based on an entrance test followed by a personal interview and group discussion.
Placements
Narsee Monjee Institute of Management Studies (NMIMS)
SCMHRD
Symbiosis Institute of Business Management (SIBM) Pune
Infrastructure and faculty
NMIMS
SCMHRD
SIBM
Overall all institutes are good for and the admission process of all institutes is also not that tough. But if we particularly talk about placements then NMIMS and SIBM are better than SCMHRD and NMIMS even has a record of 100% placement last year. With this, all institutes have an engaging and encouraging environment.
Yes, pursuing an MBA in Business Analytics from SCMHRD or an MBA from SIBM Bangalore can be rewarding.
MBA in Business Analytics is a comparatively new course at SCMHRD, but it has performed exceptionally well, in last few years. This course covers R, Python, MySQL, Tableau, and the application of these subjects in other subjects like Marketing Analytics, Operation Analytics, Risk Analytics, etc. There are also subjects related to Machine Learning, Artificial Intelligence, Big Data, Data Mining, etc. Here are some details regarding SCMHRD Business Analytics. The course includes a mandatory live project. Through the live project, you will get to work with different companies.
SIBM Bangalore MBA is also a good option in terms of placements, faculty and ROI. According to the 2021 highlights of SIBM Bangalore MBA placements, the median CTC was INR 10 LPA. While INR 32 LPA was the highest CTC offered by the recruiters.
SIBM Pune has a slight edge over SCMHRD. It is the first campus of Symbiosis and has a legacy of more than four decades. It has a wider and stronger alumni network. The cutoff for the two campuses varies only by 0.2-0.4 percentile with SIBM having the higher cutoff most years.
SIBM Pune placements have been pretty good over the last few years. According to the placement highlights of 2022, the average CTC offered to the students was INR 23.06 LPA. The highest CTC offered was INR 45.5 LPA.
If you are interested in pursuing a degree in human resources management from one of the top B schools in India, you may want to consider SCMHRD. This institute is known for its strong reputation in the field of HR and can provide you with the skills and knowledge necessary to succeed in this competitive industry. On the other hand, if you are primarily interested in obtaining an IIM degree, then IIM Ranchi may be a good option for you. While IIM Ranchi is considered to be one of the best among the newer IIMs, it may not have the same level of prestige or reputation as some of the more established institutes.
If your primary goal is to increase your chances of being placed in a top company and obtaining a high salary package in the field of HR, then SCMHRD may be a more suitable choice. It is important to carefully consider your goals and priorities before making a decision on which business school to attend.
SCMHRD offers specialization programs including Project Feasibility and Finance, Transportation, Energy, and Urban Infrastructure in the field of Infrastructure Management (IM). SCMHRS has been accredited with grade ‘A’ by NAAC.
Whereas the Symbiosis School of Banking and Finance offers both the MBA and certificate program in the field of Banking and Finance. SSBF was awarded as “Management College of the Year” by Higher Education Review Magazine in 2019 and ranked 10th by Innovative Zone Magazine as Best Educational Institute in India.
The course fees at the institutes are as follows.
Year |
Year 1 |
Year 2 |
SCMHRD MBA IM |
? 610000 |
? 590000 |
SSBF |
? 640000 |
? 640000 |
Scholarships:
SCMHRD MBA IM:
The SCMHRD offers scholarships to the MBA students declared topper in the first semester, which can cover up to 50% of tuition fee waivers.
To receive a scholarship for a perceivable future, students have to maintain a minimum GPA of 7.50.
SSBF:
SSBF offers the following scholarships and awards to its deserving students.
Post Graduate Merit Scholarship awarded to the semester topper student with a minimum of 7.50 GPA.
Scholarship by University Sports Board awarded to the 05 outstanding sportsmen and sportswomen.
Late Jayatee Deshmukh Best Outgoing Girl Student Gold Medal Award.
Placement:
SCMHRD MBA IM:
A total of 93 recruiters participated in the recruitment drive for the 2018-20 batches, and 38% of students received the Pre-placement Offer.
The highest CTC received by the student was 15.4 LPA, the average CTC received was 12.1 LPA, and the top 25% of candidates received 14.7 LPA.
The top recruiters include Wipro, Capgemini, Bajaj Auto, Boston Scientific, Reliance Industries, Mahindra & Mahindra, and many more.
SSBF:
SSBF provides placement assistance to final year students. The institute holds a record of 100% recruitment.
The highest CTC offered to a candidate was 10.11 LPA, and the average CTC received is 7.11 LPA.
A wide range of roles is offered to the students which include Relationship Manager, Wealth Management, Product Management, Credit Manager, Operation, Channel Officer, Retail Branch Banking, etc.
The top recruiters visiting the campus are CRISIL, JP Morgan Chase, HDFC Bank, ICICI Bank, Care Ratings, etc.
Above are the key points about SCMHRD MBA IM and SSBF, one can distinguish them both using those points and can make a decision.
MICA university holds 12th rank issued by outlook in 2019. Admissions in this university are based on entrance tests followed by personal interview and counseling. Placements at this university are really good.
Symbiosis Center for Management & Human Resource Development (SCMHRD) holds 13th rank for MBA issued by times. Admissions for MBA are based on entrance tests followed by personal interview and group discussion.
Tabulated below gives a brief overview of both institutions:
Particulars |
SCMHRD |
MICA |
Application fee |
1000 INR |
1,965 INR |
Top recruiters |
Accenture, ACCENTURE, Avalon Consulting, Axis Bank, Bajaj Auto, Barclays Bank, Bridgei2 |
Raymond, Titan, Saavn, Walmart, Amazon, Google, Apollo, Linkedin, YesBank, Amazon, Puma, Usha and Topline |
Average salary |
15.6 lakhs |
12.8 lakhs |
Admission process
MICA
SCMHRD
Placements
SCMHRD
MICA
Infrastructure
SCMHRD
MICA
Overall both institutes are equally good for management. The admission process of both institutes is based on entrance tests conducted by institutes. Placements of both the institutes are equally good. Both institutes have an engaging and encouraging environment.