Both the colleges are best in providing quality education. The latest ranking of the IIEST is 19. Whereas, BITS, Goa is placed in the top 100. However, one should not judge the colleges based on rankings and branding. Here is more about each college in detail.
IIEST, Shibpur-
Admissions & Fee:
The college has several programs in graduate, postgraduate, and doctoral programs. The college accepts students based on the performance in JEE Main, GATE, CAT/XAT/MAT.
The fee for B.Tech courses is 1.37 lakhs.
Placements:
The college has good placement records. The highest and average salary of the students is 39.12 LPA and 9 LPA respectively.
More than 100 companies provide offers to students in various fields with the highest salaries.
Top companies visiting the campus are Snapdeal, Wipro, Intel, Infosys, Google, Microsoft, Cognizant, Foster Wheeler, Hindustan, Hyundai Motors, Accenture, Capgemini, etc.
Faculty and Other Facilities:
The faculty at this college hold the highest degrees in their respective fields. Also, most of the professors are awarded several honors.
The facilities at the college include sports facilities, wifi, hospitals, labs, library, hostels, cafes, etc.
The library has over 200,000 books and is one of the oldest libraries.
BITS-Pilani, Goa-
Admissions & Fee:
The college offers several programs under B.E, M.Sc, M.E, and Ph.D. It accepts students based on the GATE and BITSAT entrance exam performances.
The annual fee for BE students is 3.99 lakhs.
Placements:
The placement rate is 100%. The highest and average salaries of the students are 1.2 crore and 5 lakhs.
Each year several companies visit the campus and recruit 100s of students.
Some of the top companies visiting the campus are Oracle, Adobe, Amazon, Gen pact, IBM, Capgemini, eBay, Aditya Birla, Facebook, HDFC, Google, etc.
Faculty and Other Facilities:
The campus has the best faculty with the utmost facilities.
The facilities offered by the college are gyms, medical, library, games, wi-fi, stationery, bakery, post office, etc.
This is all about the IIEST and BITS-Pilani, Goa. Both offer wonderful careers with the best faculty. However, it depends on the individual to choose the college that best suits them based on several aspects.
IIT BHU CSE is a better option. It offers better placements. IIT BHU placements are amazing for CSE. Around 100% of students of the branch get placed with an average CTC of around INR 25 LPA. While the highest CTC offered is around INR 1.5 CPA. Companies such as Google, Microsoft, Facebook visit the campus placements frequently.
Being an IIT it also offers better facilities. The campus life of IIT BHU is also comparably better.
One of my friends was a student of this institute, but he did not know about the 5 years dual degree program in IIEST Shibpur. He told me that no one even knows about this new university's dual degree course; thereby, if you love to get risks, then take admission to enter here.
Besides, he told me that he was also unaware of the reputation along with the education quality of the other two institutes. However, in IIEST Shibpur, you will get immense learning opportunities; additionally, education quality is also not bad as it is an ancient institute. Rather it improves a lot after becoming INI.
It is challenging to state which institute is better if the student doesn’t know the institute properly. Besides, it is also important to understand what is actually better as the thinking of a student.
However, you are from outside of West Bengal, then IIIT Gwalior must be the first priority, although IIEST Shibpur is a reputed institute. The faculties of IIEST Shibpur are experienced enough, but most of them are Bengali. So, preference will be given to students from West Bengal, as the home state would be a great advantage. They will be able to gain all the opportunities like communication. It is because the students from West Bengal can speak in Bengali far better way than the others.
If there is a comparison between IIIT Gwalior and Jabalpur, then the suggestion will be for IIIT Gwalior, as it offers better placement than the other. Besides, it also has vastly alleged alumni and knowledgeable faculties.
If you're considering your options for higher education, it's important to do your research and choose a college that will provide you with a quality education and a strong foundation for your future career. While IIIT Bangalore is a well-respected institution that has established a strong reputation for academic excellence and innovation, IIEST Shibpur is a college that may not be as widely recognized outside of West Bengal.
It's worth noting that the quality of education and opportunities available at a college can vary widely, regardless of its reputation. While some students at IIEST Shibpur may excel academically and go on to successful careers, there may be others who struggle to find meaningful employment or face challenges in their professional development.
One issue that some people have raised with IIEST Shibpur is the prevalence of spamming and promotion within the student body. While students need to advocate for their institution and promote its strengths, this should never come at the expense of the learning environment or the overall reputation of the college. In some cases, aggressive promotion and spamming can harm the college's brand and make it more difficult for students to succeed.
It's also worth noting that the "brand value" of a college isn't always the most important factor in choosing where to study. Instead, you should consider a range of factors, including the quality of the faculty, the resources and opportunities available to students, and the overall learning environment.
In the end, the decision of where to study is a deeply personal one that will depend on your unique needs, goals, and preferences. While IIIT Bangalore may be a strong choice for some students, others may find that IIEST Shibpur offers the right combination of opportunities and resources to help them succeed. Ultimately, it's up to you to do your research, consider your options carefully, and make the decision that will set you on the path to a successful and fulfilling career.
Both IIEST and IIIT are apex institutes. While IIEST has a legacy of its own, IIIT is relatively new but shows promise. CS and Mechanical are two of the most popular engineering branches in India. IIIT offers 150 seats in CS and IIEST offers 90 seats in ME.
The table below gives a brief overview of both institutions:
Criteria | IIEST Shibpur | IIIT Pune |
NIRF Ranking | 43rd out of 200 | N/A |
Fee (First Year) | B.Tech.- Rs.1.37 Lakhs M.Tech.- Rs.81,500 | B.Tech.- Rs.2.35 Lakhs M.Tech.- Rs.1.66 Lakhs |
Eligibility | B.Tech.- 10+2 with 75%+ JEE Main M.Tech.- Pass in Graduation + GATE | B.Tech.- 10+2 with 75% + JEE Main M.Tech.- Graduation + GATE |
Admission Process | Entrance Exam | Entrance Exam + JOSAA counseling |
Campus
Facilities
Placement Statistics
Course Scope:
CS deals with designing and developing computer software and hardware processes. Major job sectors include Engineering firms, academic institutions, Sales and Marketing firms, IT/Software Companies, etc.
Mechanical Engineering involves the production, designing, and operations of machines. The employment sectors for ME include Research and Development (R&D), Design, Production, Analysis and Testing, Installation, Maintenance, etc.
Students must compare both the streams and colleges carefully. It is a personal decision and depends on an individual’s capabilities and expectations from college life.
My friend is a graduate in CSE from Jadavpur University and according to his experience here are the possible reasons you might be looking for:
When my friend joined JU, only the ETCE branch was having the best placement. But according to recent placement statistics, IT and CSE also have reached that prominence.
JU has a huge alumni base which helped my friend and his peers more than one can think of. Getting contacts and recommendations made it possible to invite a lot of companies for campus recruitment.
Both the branches, whether CST in IIEST Shibpur or ETCE in Jadavpur University is worth their name. Still, there are many factors regarding Rankings, Admission Process, Fees, Scholarships, and Placements that differentiates them.Jadavpur University acquires a spot as 17th college in BTech amongst 300 in India 2020.IIEST Shibpur, on the other hand, stands firm with 21st ranking amongst Engineering institutes, as per NIRF Ranking 2020.
Admission:
Jadavpur University:
IIEST Shibpur:
Fees:
PLACEMENTS:
Jadavpur University:
IIEST Shibpur:
Looking into the above factors, ETCE from JU proves to be a better option than CST in IIEST Shibpur in rankings, fees, placements criteria.
Between these comparisons, NIT Jamshedpur is far better than IIEST Shibpur. However, the considerations can be made for the following facts:
As per MHRD Rankings, NIT Jamshedpur is ahead of IIEST Shibpur. Thus, there is something mapping considering the oldness of an institute with its goodness. If this fact is true, then many colleges would be better rather the best than the renowned IITs.
The main thing is that the ultimate reputation and the growth of an institute generally depend on its alumni as well as funds that it gets from the Government because these two things are needed to make sure a good faculty structures.
The following table gives a brief overview of these two institutes
Criteria |
NIT Jamshedpur |
IIEST Shibpur |
Become NIT |
2002 |
2014 |
Placement Statistics |
90% |
80% |
Highest CTC |
12 LPA |
9 LPA |
Lowest CTC |
3.5 LPA |
4.2 LPA |
IIEST is a more research-driven college like IISER, and 4 years Engineering Degree does not procure from this institute. Thereby, it is completely meaningless to go for 5 years course despite being interested in doing a Ph.D. in later years.
Fees at IIEST are more, as it offers one-year extra study. Most importantly, IIEST cannot be an IIT, as there is already one IIT (Kharagpur IIT) in the state, and Modi Government already declared that there would be only IIT in one state. Besides, Jadavpur is considered a competitor if there is a chance to set up another IIT in the state.
Considering the above facts, the recommendation should be given for NIT Jamshedpur as it the best alternatives.
IIEST Shibpur hostel facilities aren’t too good. In the first year, students are allotted four sharing rooms. The rooms aren’t in great condition. Basic facilities such as 24*7 wifi facilities are there.
IIEST Shibpur placements are great. During the 2022 placement drive, 1022 companies took part in the campus placements. Highest CTC offered during the campus placement was INR 45 LPA.
IIEST Shibpur is the best place for research purposes, and if someone wants to do research and further studies in Mathematics, IIEST Shibpur can be the right choice for him/her. IIEST was ranked 7th by NIRF in the Research parameter. The overall rank of this institute is 20th in India.
MSc. in Mathematics is a two years course degree offered by IIEST.
Admissions and cut-off:
Fifty percent of the available seats to the MSc courses are admitted through Centralized Counselling for MSc.(CCMN) with mandatory JAM.
IIEST holds its own test and interview process for the rest fifty percent seats.
Requirements for admission in MSc Maths: 6.5 CGPA for OC/OBC and 6.0 for SC/ST/PWD out of 10.
Course fee:
The fees per year for an MSc degree in Maths is around INR 41,500.
Other facilities:
Both Pure and Applied Mathematics for a Master of Science degree is offered here.
A unique DTP facility laboratory is provided for MSc. Mathematics.
Placements- Most students of MSc Mathematics choose higher studies after the compilation of the course. The median salary offered to the students at the institute in placements is 6.5 LPA.
Being one of the most prestigious colleges in India, IIEST Shibpur has received many accolades over the past. It offers all the necessary facilities that a research student will need and offers great placement to the students. Getting admission in this college is tough, as the best students from all over the country try to take admission here. So, if you want to pursue a career in Mathematics then there should not be any second thoughts about joining IIEST Shibpur.